http://bit.ly/buy-fm22Football Manager videos you can learn something from. The chances are that you will already know how the (Pro), (Amb) & (Det) tests turn out, but the Morale thing is a little different so might be worth checking out. They might be kept around to flesh out the U19's or the U23's, but every time I look at them I know they're just a filler and I don't care about their development. He left Man Utd with their great facilities and coaches and went to play for Preston in the 3rd Division, (would now be League 2). and what seemed strange to me is that the preview with the highest rating of B was still a golden generation, but Preview (with just 1 A rating), wasn't classed as a golden generation. It's well worth a look. Sports Interactive 2016 By Improving youth recruitment, youth facilities, and hiring a top head of youth development will undoubtedly lead to fruitful results on youth intake day. 1. I think we are all guilty of working hard to understand how something works and then just assuming that it will stay the same. I have to admit that i did not know that i am thinking about doing a new Africanos Braganca style save (Cape Verde regens in Portugal) but this time again with Caley Braves (French Regens in Scotland), might post something about that (dynamic youth rating, nationalities etc). Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases from Amazon.com. So they are being rated against how good your existing players are now rather than how good they might become in the future. Highest PA 161. One is called Game Importance and the other one is Youth Rating. 8. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc or its affiliates, Here Are The Best Complete Forwards In FM23, Here Are The Best Deep Lying Forwards In FM23, The Best Way to Use Inverted Wing Backs in Football Manager. 26.24Control Group Average PA. 73.09Minimal Facilities Average PA. 33.01. Regens enter your game's database on specific dates throughout the season. Injury susceptibility. This stat affects the order in which Youth Intakes happen for loaded leagues, even: weve noted that the clubs with the best Youth Recruitment within a country will receive their regens first. Now at the end of season 1 after the youth intake, some big clubs are interested in my best players from the youth intake, wich are on a youth contract and i cant do nothing about them leaving. What happens if I edit the Youth Rating, both before the preview and after? Nationality. From what I remember seeing elsewhere, on the preview day the range for CA/PA is set for each player (e.g. . That way I can do a little bit of this and then return to playing my own save and then come back and do a little bit of this again. That ties in completely with the preview, (which surprises me a little if I'm honest). In this instance, and usingHenrique Simal andHenrique Honorato as examples just because they have 2 names which makes them stand out, let's look at their CA/PA. Then we have the players with high PA, (I'm playing this save and looking at the PA so I know the difference between PA and PPA), who aren't quite ready for Liga 2. What happens if you compare 10 different Youth Intakes from the same preview to 10 different intakes from 10 different previews? If you are trying to add regens to your shortlist from multiple intake months this may not work due to size, you need to do each month individually. The last true golden generation for Dynamo Kyiv was incidentally also a class of 92-93. Intake was observed in October, but it didn't seem based on division. If your squad already has the likes of Mbapp and Haaland, do not expect many 4 or 5 star potential youngsters. Then there are the players who are good enough to play in theLiga Portugal 2 SABSEG, so I send them out on loan to another Liga 2 side. 4 players at 150+ PA. Highest PA 179. Initially I was going to pick a small Nation (to reduce processing time), and then I was going to select a commonly used structure, (England) & a well known club, (Man Utd), (that more people could relate to), but in the end decided to go with the Brazilian structure because quite simply they produce the best Newgens, (due to their high Nation Youth rating and Game Importance). Clubs with high youth recruitment ratings are often the clubs that get the best youth intakes. Football Manager 2022 - Youth Intake Guide, How Youth Recruitment Affects Youth Intake, Free-transferrable Players (by 2021) Shortlist. Highest PA 178. What is the difference in terms of development, between a player spending a season in the U19's and the same player spending a season in the U23's? @fc.cadonilinked me to the above Youtube account and I've only had a look at 1 video but I've been really impressed actually. 17. Media Handling style. This "preferred" position will ALWAYS 100% of the time be 1 of the Natural Ability positions. Date of birth/Age. For a start there isn't a lot of info there, and I complained for quite a while that the information it did contained had very little, (if any), direct impact on the Youth Intake itself, (although it appears as if those issues have now been resolved and the preview is indeed a snapshot into what will be coming you way later in the season). Highest CA 103. In terms of player development is there an experiment that we could run that would compare development of players who stayed in the U19's, players who were given a couple/few outings in the 1st Team, and the same player going out on loan at a lower level? The Football Manager 2023 winter transfer update includes a number of essential changes to the FM23 database. (Quality of opposition, quality of teammates, facilities, staff etc) If you have high potential but not good enough right this moment. Today, Jake takes a look at how you can improve youth intakes in FM2023 so you can. Or is that what is best for the player? Its pretty easy, actually, but well hidden. I don't have the CA and PA numbers on, as much as I don't know how as any other reason. Youth intake day is one of the most exciting in the Football Manager calendar. Trademarks and brands are the property of their respective you can check out this one about comparing development. I have added this to the list on page #6. FM22 Youth Intakes are one o the best parts of football manager. In my opinion the Ajax thread is the best FM related thread on these forums, (had to be specific because the OTF guys get funny), and even though it's hugely out of date now, I still urge anyone who hasn't read it to go and read it, and maybe even if you have read it, go back and read it again. What happens if I edit the Professional status of the club, both before the preview and after? It's not my channel, but something which I like to watch. A Head of Youth Development will affect new players in two ways. If you look at post 2, you will see that there are 10 different Youth Intake previews. He was absolutely being "Driven by the evidence". I'm not one usually to link to my own threads, but in this instance I don't know of anyone playing the same way that I am in this save. Highest PA 169. @Mandy42. The backroom staff are adamant they want Azeez to go out on loan. (An important distinction). Just remember that this is a tiny tiny tiny sample size. Media description. (So think of them as 11, 12, 13, 14 & 15 years olds all playing aged group football). Below that I don't understand at all how it works. That being said, even if I am to take what you have said as absolute gospel, (and in fact I do believe that it certainly used to be done this way), there is no guarantee that what was done in the past is what is being done now. 5. Highest CA 100. We have already clarified that Nationalities are static haven't we? To reflect the real-life transfer window and other changes in the global football world, the new FM23 patch includes all the latest football transfers, loan deals, staff movements, changes to clubs' transfer budgets and their . The fact that the problem is limited to CA only suggests that there is some sort of modifier being added to these figures to make them like this. CA. The level in that Youth Team at the time was ridiculous, (when you think that the likes of Keith Gillespie, Robbie Savage, Chris Casper, Ben Thornley John O'Kane, Kevin Pilkington, Simon Davies, (no, not that one), and a few others that I can't remember), all went on to have decent Pro careers it's absolutely ridiculous. In comparison to Man Utd they have rubbish facilities and rubbish staff, but he hasn't swapped playing for Man Utd in the Premier League for playing for Preston in League 2, he's swapped playing for the U19's in the U19's for playing competitive League 2 football against men, so the jump in standard would have been significant. RIght? While Azeez is guaranteed three and a half, with a possible advancement to four and a half. 10. Rather than using the words "more important", I think there is more control that you can exert over the development of a younger player, (such as PPM's and additional focus), but if a player is ready for Senior football at 17, (and that involves a loan elsewhere), then I think there certainly isn't a hard and fast rule to say that he will develop better playing for the U19's at home rather than the 1st Team at a lower level. First, go to the World Icon on the top-right side of the screen, then look for "Transfers" and filter by "Youth Intake" and Brazil. I "think"* what happens now is that the player rates your player against the player at your club best able to play in that position, (and how good he is in that position rather than how good he is in his best position). This one will be particularly interesting for me. 7. Let's just ignore the 1st Team squad because they won't play for the B Team anyway, but after them we have the players who are good enough to play for a Liga Bwin side but who are not good enough to get in our 1st Team so they go out on loan. One of the hardest things in Football Manager - after not putting your fist through the screen when you concede a 95th minute equaliser against Luton - is learning how to develop youth players in FM22. What is the difference in terms of development, between a player spending a season in the U19's and the same player spending a season in the U23's? So don't worry so much about actual CA and PA, (never mind about PCA and PPA). A high PA young player with low CA is not likely to get 1st team opportunities, (because he's not good enough right now), so he would probably benefit from going out on loan. Well with regards to Nationalities I'm afraid that's not the case because it's changed and is no longer set at the Youth Intake Preview. "Players by preferred positions" means the position that the player prefers to play in doesn't it? We were expecting something close to 32 and we actually got 82, (256% bigger than we expected). Some lower division intake was observed on January. Home Dressing Room - General FM and Football Discussion - II, The Dark Pictures Anthology: The Devil in Me. Which I doubt had that much of an impact on his career. In your example above, the highest PA moved between the 160-180 range. This was how it had been explained and this is how we understood it to work. As the club we're experimenting with in Spain is actually Melilla, (who are based on the African mainland), I would expect to see more Africans and certainly more Moroccans, but whether that's incorporated into the game I don't know. We determined at the very start of the thread, that in FM22, Nationalities were static from the point of the Youth Intake Preview and would never change. 18+ - game time is more important, so if you aren't playing them in first team games at least 15 minutes a game, better to send them on loan to a level where they will get game time. There are 8 levels of Youth Recruitment, and to see it, you . At the moment I'm just sticking a few through just to get it started. Place of birth. The more leagues you include in your database, the more clubs and leagues that will be included by default. There was a suggestion that all the facilities have 10 levels and another suggestion that some had 10 levels and some had 8 levels. Favoured Personnel. Then this is the guide for you. The video I looked at concerned the impact of (Pro), (Amb), (Det) and Morale on player growth with is pretty relevant to this thread and I really liked it. Where to start? There are absolutely players I failed to develop properly, (especially in the early seasons of the save), and even now there are players that I fail with. It was largely due to their combined talent, that Dynamo had its period of greatest domestic and international success. i tried this with many teams as i wanted to check whether this works or not. Thanks. I'm not saying that the whole squad became Pro footballers, but I think we're already up to about 12 or 13 and that is absolutely ridiculous! A high PA young player with low CA is not likely to get 1st team opportunities, (because he's not good enough right now), so he would probably benefit from going out on loan. Whether you're looking for tips or you're experiencing the big day for the first time, we've got all the info so you can be prepared for youth intake day in FM22. For example I'm sure there are absolutely LOADS of people who are unaware that Average/Adequate on Junior Coaching is the wrong way round. Or does it mean the position that the HoYD would prefer to play the player in? Once again I will say before delving into this, that the sample size of 10 intakes we're using here is tiny, but let's just go with it for a minute. Mika Biereth an 18 year old forward and Miguel Azeez 19 year old midfielder. Then you open up that inbox message They just lie and lie and lie some more. We have Total CA and Total PA for each player 3 and 4 from the right. Youth intake day signals the arrival of 'newgens' - players that were not previously in the game but have been generated and enrolled by SI. When you purchase Training Facilities allowed players at the club to improve, Youth Facilities allowed the Youth players, (not yet through the intake), to improve, Junior Coaching largely impacted on Newgen CA and Youth Recruitment largely impacted on Newgen PA. Something has caught my eye when posting the 1st few results and when it happened again, (but even more pronounced this time), I decided that it wasn't just my brain playing tricks on me so I would mention it and look at it. It's tempting to stay with so many good youngsters but this is #journeyman #FM21 https://t.co/imx8yjr1Xu" 7 players at 120+ PA. Technically speaking 2 of the MC's can also play SC, we have a 3rd MC, an AML and a GK. Santander Bank branch locations in Funes, Spain with addresses, opening hours, phone numbers, and more information including directions, maps, and nearby locations. After all, a L20 Training Facility is a flippin enormous investment. Some Lower Division got intake in Late December. The PA result was a little better, coming out on top of both minimum facilities and maximum training groups. 3 players at 150+ CA. This is simply an error that SI made when these levels were introduced, but for whatever reason they have decided not to correct the order in Junior Coaching. Hopefully I will be able to do so at some point in the future. By playing him "up" at a level before he's actually ready, I have advanced his development. What's in a name eh? Secondary Nation players in other circumstances is something that could be looked at though, especially the relation with staff and affiliates. @SoSolidSnake What happens if I edit the HoYD info, both before the preview and after? This should help to show something like lowering the youth facilities reducing the PA of individual players but if your Youth Recruitment is high, you're still getting the same volume of players coming through, and vice versa, do we care about youth recruitment if we're still getting high individual PA players coming through with regularity. The last thing I would say though is that the CA/PA stars lie. 7. You might be a manager who swaps from 1 formation to another and there is a distinct lack of width in this preview, so if you were relying on a fringe wide player to come in and make an impact then you're unlikely to be happy come intake day. If there is just 1 thing that you take from this thread then please let it be this. Next up is the Youth Facilities. That makes sense. I have added the following points to post #6. I'm showing more than my usual interest. i did some analysis myself in my topic but nothing compared to what you are doing. What caught my eye previously, but especially in the last results, was how many times the CA or PA ended in a 0, (so 10, 20, 30, 40 etc etc etc). So not how good the player actually is, but how good whoever is compiling the reports things he is). I'm not sure that Geographic location will be used like this, but then again it seems pretty reasonable. I sign everyone from my youth intake every year, and I know for a fact that some of these players, after a year or maybe two, will all of a sudden have a lot higher PA than on youth intake day. Before I get into the next experiment, I had a conversation with a few people recently with regards to the different levels within the facilities. Height. 6. 15. Control Group Average CA. I know I certainly am. What happens if I reduce/increase the Youth Recruitment/Junior Coaching both before preview and after? Intake Distribution by preferred position. (I "think"* that a staff member on the favoured personnel list influences the make-up of a plyer, but I don't know how). It's lazy and it needs to be called out more in my opinion. I will add it to the list. There was a high profile example of a really good Italian GK who had the dreaded (L.Det) (Unamb) mix and it just didn't work with him. A HoYD with Technical as his playing style will produce players with high Technical attributes. If two clubs have identical Youth Recruitment, then the club with the highest Reputation will get the better players and will get their Youth Intake day first. Developing our youngsters into world beaters brings an almost unparalleled sense of satisfaction, and FM21 gives us more control over the youth development process than ever before. Highest PA 170. I have lots of questions and I will try too go through all of them between now and when FM23 comes out, (it's going to take a while), so I may start listing them. I knew from this season that their squad was seriously young. We often lose many of the 1st half of the season games, and then come strong in the 2nd half as the players have half a season playing at this level under their belts and are improving rapidly. Yeah, if I had a penny for every time I had seen that I would have. lots of pennies. More than them staying in my U23 team where they use training facilities and staff I have control over the quality of. Design Without further ado, let's get into it. PPA. These were obtained from the game itself and cross-checked between different saves, so were absolutely certain that theyre correct. You're dreaming about bringing through a 200 PA striker who will make Erling Haaland look like Yaya Sanogo. (Perceived CA. Prince Ekpolo FM23 Profile, Stats and Attributes, Alfons Serra FM23 Profile, Stats and Attributes, Andr Seruca FM23 Profile, Stats and Attributes, Tho Vermot FM23 Profile, Stats and Attributes. I "think" the only location that is taken into account is the "Region" the club is in, (in this case Western Europe). Initially I posted a reply to the video, (and no I'm not going to link to it in here), but I deleted my post and instead of telling you what I know and what I think, I'm going to run some experiments and let the results speak for themselves. So the info here comes from his ability to judge players, (both in terms of CA and PA). Your club gets a fresh pack of Newgens and every year you have the hope that at least one of those virtual kids has the potential to become one of your star players. This will happen from time to time even when they have the best rating of 20 in judging player ability and judging player potential. The yearly Youth Intake is a moment a lot of managers love. (Perceived PA). Best FM22 Wonderkids FM22 Players Under 25 FM22 Transfer Budgets FM22 Youth Facilities Graphic Megapacks Cut Out Facepack V2023.06 - 10 Feb 2023 . Most of the information was correct but not everything(for example that every wonderkid would go for Portugal and not Cape verde, while i produced three wonderkids and they all became Cape Verde internationals. On the day of the youth intake, your newgens could be between the ages of 14 and 16, with varying levels of current ability and potential ability. (Both footedness has a cost in terms of CA, it stands to reason that if the attributes change then so must the preferred foot info). Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Is there any truth to this or is it just an old FM players tale? 15. In terms of CA, this group came out the lowest so far, (lower than the minimum facilities where they were all set at 1). great work jim really interesting to read. In this case I have an idea for editing the staff members to extreme personalities and then tracking how this impacts on players who come through the intake with them on their favoured personnel list, but that's a long way away at this stage). Getting a youth intake in football manager that has the description has the potential to be a real golden generation for the club is really rare and most of the time is just due to luck. Feel free to suggest others, (but no promise that I will get to them). The chances are we will lose him, (by about age 26/27 at the latest I think), and I need to have other options because I can't just go out and buy someone to replace him. The accuracy of player judgement from your staff will also come into play, as they do not get to see the exact value of a players potential or current ability. The cost will appear as "Ground Maintenance". PCA. Highest PA 177. with that kind of honed in searching, finding a quality player to fill your team's needs should be doable. As a result I have 2x 18 year old DR's 1x 21 year old DR, 1x 22 year old DR and a 23 year old DR. Once I have developed them I will either loan them out or sell them to generate income, but the big thing is I have to develop them 1st so that when and if I do need to go and buy someone, I will know that I have these 5 right backs that I have developed to a level that they can all come in and do a job for us. 3 players at 150+ PA. I was always personally a bit skeptical about this, but if SI make the game then surely they are going to know more than some old bloke who can't even be bothered to run an experiment to prove if what he things is true, is actually true? We have a CA and a PA score for each player across 10 different intakes. 77/153 68/146 69/142 72/157 78/177 83/187 70/146 73/153 67/134 76/155 His PA ranges from 142-187 which according to my basic understanding doesn't fit him into any 1 of the existing ranges. Regarding this, there are two range of dates that the game seems to use: We werent able to determine if geographical location has anything to do with countries being placed in one or another, but knowing the dates should be enough. What Does Golden Generation Mean in Football Manager? My plan is to properly dissect this to death, but I'm not going to be doing it all in 1 go. Surface Studio vs iMac - Which Should You Pick? I should add that unfortunately [Name redacted] aren't alone in chatting absolute rubbish about things they know very little about I should have done this long before now but we all know how real life is. If a couple move into the U23s as backup, and another one makes the 1st team, you're doing well. The youth intake are generally bad and unfortauntely set in stone. There are things you can do to improve your youth intakes in FM 21. Just like in the real world, it is just not realistic to have potential superstars coming out of your youth system each year.